3 December, 2010, CHENNAI – The results of analyses of soil, sediment and ground water samples
collected by Community Environmental Monitoring (CEM) “conclusively demonstrate that the Sterlite
Industries (India) Ltd’s copper smelter complex in Tuticorin (SIIL) is endangering human health and
the environment and contaminating water supplies,” according to an expert opinion given by Dr. Mark
Chernaik, staff scientist at Oregon, USA-based Environmental Law Alliance Worldwide.
“The situation is like in Bhopal, where vast areas of land and groundwater are seriously contaminated.
There is no doubt that Sterlite has harmed the environment and the rights of future generations. We
want the Supreme Court to take into account the damage has already occurred and direct the
company to shut down and clean up,” said Nainar Kulasekaran, an 80-year old farmer who leads the
Thoothukudi Anti-Sterlite Struggle Committee. December 3 is the 26th Anniversary of the Bhopal gas
Soil, sediment and slag samples collected by CEM at the behest of the Struggle Committee revealed
exceedingly high levels of heavy metals, including iron, arsenic, cadmium and nickel. The samples
were tested at Chennai-based Sargam Labs, which is recognised by the Ministry of Environment &
A soil sample collected from the backyard of a residence in Therku Veerapandiapuram village
contained 3,35,602 mg/kg of iron. At such levels, accidental ingestion of just 3.5 grams can cause
serious poisoning in a child, according to Dr. Chernaik’s analysis. Consuming larger quantities can be
lethal. Symptoms of iron poisoning range from abdominal pain, vomiting, diarrhea and damage to the
intestine. Other effects include heart, liver and central nervous system damage. The owner of the
residence said the soil in the backyard was brought from near the Sterlite factory to raise the level of
Arsenic levels at the same location were 532 mg/kg – ten times higher than permissible value for
residential soil in the UK, and more than 50 times the mean background levels for arsenic. Inorganic
arsenic is carcinogenic in humans, most commonly producing skin, bladder and lung cancers through
inhalation and ingestion.
Cadmium, which causes lung cancer and is toxic to kidney and bones, was ten times above average
background levels in the backyard soil sample, while Nickel which causes skin allergies and bronchitis
was also found at elevated levels.
A sediment sample collected from the Kalangarai stream that drains the run-off from Sterlite’s gypsum
dump contained 28,643 mg/kg of iron – 477 times above levels that can cause serious health effects.
Arsenic levels were nearly 8 times higher than the Environmental Screening Criteria by the New
Jersey Department of Environment. Cadmium at 26.5 times above, and chromium, copper, lead, nickel
and zinc too were elevated above NJDEP’s screening levels. Responding to reports that goats from
Milavittan village regularly fall sick or die after grazing near the stream, Dr. Chernaik reports that “It
would only take a goat to ingest 73 grams of this sediment to develop serious clinical symptoms of iron
poisoning.” Villagers in Milavittan say cattle rearing has drastically come down because cattle fall sick
frequently and die prematurely due to pollution from Sterlite.
Agriculture too has suffered. A water sample from an open well collected from a farm near Sterlite’s
slag dump was found to be “completely unsuitable for use in irrigation” because of the high levels of
salinity. According to the Food and Agriculture Organisation, salinity levels above 2000 mg/litre can
cause severe damage to crops. The water in the open well had a salinity level of 7854 mg/litre –
nearly four times the level at which severe crop damage can occur.
Another sample of water from a handpump in Therku Veerapandiapuram contained sulphate levels
nearly 10 times above levels that can cause gastrointestinal effects.
The well water and the handpump sample contained high levels of calcium – an integral component of
gypsum, also known as Calcium Sulphate dihydrate. Given that Sterlite generates and dumps large
quantities of gypsum in the vicinity, Dr. Chernaik concludes that Sterlite is the most likely cause of
contamination of the groundwater.
In September, the Madras High Court allowed two writ petitions and directed the closure of Sterlite’
copper smelter for violating environmental laws. Sterlite has managed to get relief from the Supreme
Court, where the matter is pending and will be posted for hearing on December 13, 2010.
For more information, contact:
Nityanand Jayaraman: 9444082401. Adviser, Community Environmental Monitoring.
Fatima Babu (Thoothukudi): 9443404855
Issued by Community Environmental Monitoring, a program of The Other Media
H31/39, Ashtalakshmi Gardens, Besant Nagar, Chennai 600 090
- Dr. Mark Chernaik Opinion Letter 1 Dec 2010
- Comparison of Water sample results from sources around SIIL, Tuticorin with the Indian and other
Standards November 2010
- Comparison of SIIL Sediment Results with the New Jersey Department of Environment (NJDEP) – Environment Screening Criteria (ESC)1 and any other international standards November 2010